In late October 2019, soon after they began dating after meeting on Carpool Karaoke, the pair took a major step in their romance and became Instagram official. Following their date at Universal's Halloween Horror Nights, Zooey and Jonathan took to social media to share glimpses into their frightening evening. As the New Girl alum wrote, "Still processing how scared I was of these people dressed in spooky masks."
The actress made the purrrfect plus one to his brother's Halloween wedding.
During Thanksgiving 2019, the Property Brothers star professed his love to Zooey, publicly dropping the "L" word in his Instagram caption. "I am beyond thankful to be surrounded by such incredibly fun loving people & puppies," he wrote to his one million followers. "You bring joy to my life. I love you."
After two months together, the couple made their red carpet debut at the Critics' Choice Documentary Awards in November 2019.
The force was strong during their Star Wars double date with Drew Scott and wife Linda Phan.
The duo has a fun date night at the Emma premiere in Los Angeles.
In April 2020, the couple took to Facebook Live to do a reading of Jonathan and his twin brother's children's book, Builder Brothers: Big Plans.
Ringing in the New Year, Zooey gushed over Jonathan on Instagram, writing, "My 2020 MVP was this guy, who always made me feel happy in spite of a weird and uncertain year," she gushed. "Hoping 2021 is full of silver linings for everyone."
The couple announced their engagement in August 2023, with the pair gushing on Instagram, "Forever starts now!!!"